Radical Market Research Idea #6: Don’t calculate p-values #MRX

p-values are the backbone of market research. Every time we complete a study, we run all of our data through a gazillion statistical tests and  search for those that are significant. Hey, if you’re lucky, you’ll be working with an extremely large sample size and everything will be statistically significant. More power to you!

But what if you didn’t calculate p-values? What if you simply looked at the numbers and decided if the difference was meaningful? What if you calculated means and standard deviations, and focused more on effect sizes and less on p<0.05? Instead of relying on some statistical test to tell you that you chose a sample size large enough to make the difference significant, what if you used your brain to decide if the difference between the numbers was meaningful enough to warrant taking a decision?

Effect sizes are such an underused, unappreciated measure in market research. Try them. You’ll like them. Radical?

Really Simple Statistics: 1-Tail and 2-Tail tests #MRX

Welcome to Really Simple Statistics (RSS). There are lots of places online where you can ponder over the minute details of complicated equations but very few places that make statistics understandable to everyone. I won’t explain exceptions to the rule or special cases here. Let’s just get comfortable with the fundamentals.

What are tails?

No, not these tails.


monosodium demondimum nasirkhan moneysaver67 from morguefile

The tails in statistics refer to the predictions we make about our research results and how we want to hedge our bets.

One tailed tests

One tailed tests are what you use when you have a specific guess. Men are taller than women. Women like chocolate more than men like chocolate. Roses smell nicer than tulips. It’s like putting all your eggs in one basket. Take a guess and hold yourself to it.


xandert from morguefile

Ideally, this is what you should be aiming for. You should have a prediction about what is going to happen before you conduct your research. You should do your homework and not just willy nilly see ‘what comes up significant.’

One tailed tests are advantageous because they give you a better chance of generating differences that turn out to be statistically significant, as long as, of course, your prediction turned out to be right.

Two tailed tests

Two tailed tests are used when you can’t make a guess. Will men or women eat more bread? Is basketball or soccer more fun? Do people spend more on coffee or on hot chocolate? In this case, you’re putting splitting your eggs between two baskets – maybe men but maybe women, maybe basketball but maybe soccer.


jdurham from morguefile
.
In reality, most of what we do in market research is based on two tailed tests. We don’t spend the time to develop specific hypotheses ahead of time. We wait to get the datatables and then search through hundreds of pages looking for whatever happens to be significant.

And that’s it! Really Simple Statistics!

2d pie

Really Simple Statistics: p values #MRX

Welcome to Really Simple Statistics (RSS). There are lots of places online where you can ponder over the minute details of complicated equations but very few places that make statistics understandable to everyone. I won’t explain exceptions to the rule or special cases here. Let’s just get comfortable with the fundamentals.

What is a p value?

P value is a short form for probability value and another way of saying significance value. It refers to the chance that you are willing to take in being wrong. (I know, once in your life is too many times to be wrong.)

No matter how careful you are, random chance plays a part in everything. If you try to guess whether you’ll get heads or tails when you flip a coin, your chance of guessing correctly is only 50%. Half the time, you’ll flip tails even if you wanted to flip heads.p value

In research, we don’t like 50/50 odds. We instead only want to risk that 5% or 1% of our predictions are wrong. And, if you just  picked 1% or 5%, you’ve just picked a peck of picked peppers. Whoops, I mean you’ve just picked a p value.

P values are almost always expressed out of 1. For example, a p value of 0.05 means you are willing to let 5% of your predictions be wrong. A p value of 0.1 means you are willing to let 10% of them be wrong. Don’t let that pesky decimal place fool you. A p value of 0.01 means 1% and a p value of 0.1 means 10%.p value

When you do a statistical test in software like SPSS or Systat, it will tell you the exact p value associated with your specific set data. For instance, it might indicate that the p value of your result is 0.035, or “Men are significantly taller than women, p=0.035.” That means there is a 3.5% chance that men are NOT actually taller than women and this result happened only because of random chance.

Really Simple Statistics!

Data Tables: The scourge of falsely significant results #MRX

Histogram of sepal widths for Iris versicolor ...

Image via Wikipedia

Who doesn’t have fond thoughts of 300 page data tabulation reports! Page after page of crosstab after crosstab, significance test after significance test. Oh, it’s a wonderful thing and it’s easy as pie (mmmm…. pie) to run your fingers down the rows and columns to identify all of the differences that are significant. This one is different from B, D, F, and G. That one is different from D, E, and H. Oh, the abundance of surprise findings! Continue reading

5 random things I like about statistics and proof you are a dork

Plot of a boxplot.

Image via Wikipedia

You are a dork. The proof is that you thought a blog post about statistics might be interesting. I admire your strange interest in statistics.

  1. I like how trend lines become straighter and straighter as you increase the sample size
  2. I like how box plots convey everything you need to know about a distribution
  3. I like 3 dimensional maps where the axes take you hours to name and then you go “duh, of course!”
  4. I like mahalanobis distance, cronbachs alpha, and factor analysis.
  5. I like how effect sizes can make statistical significance irrelevant.

Again, your turn!

Read these too

  • What Ethnographers Do: Interview Guide (via Patterns of Play)
  • Top 9 Lame Excuses to Behave Unethically #MRX
  • Researchers do it… with ethics
  • Would you prefer to kill someone over helping families? #MRX
  • What every market research client wants in their Christmas stocking #MRX